Rankfill

Keyword in URL: Does It Still Matter for SEO in 2024?

You're setting up a new page and you pause at the URL field. Should it be /best-project-management-software or /our-software-features? You've heard keywords in URLs help SEO, but you've also heard Google is "smarter now" and it doesn't matter anymore. You don't want to over-optimize. You also don't want to leave easy ranking signals on the table.

Here's the honest answer: keywords in URLs still matter — but much less than they did five years ago, and far less than most of the checklist tools will tell you. What actually matters is more nuanced than a yes/no.

What Google Has Said About Keywords in URLs

Google's John Mueller confirmed in a 2021 webmaster Q&A that keywords in URLs are a "very small ranking factor." He went further: if you're considering changing existing URLs just to add keywords, the disruption from losing link equity and crawl history isn't worth whatever tiny signal you'd gain.

That framing is useful. It tells you two things:

  1. The signal exists — it's not zero
  2. It's marginal enough that it should never drive major decisions

The main value of a keyword in a URL is legibility — to users and to Google's crawlers. A URL like /affordable-crm-for-freelancers communicates the page's topic clearly. That clarity helps Google categorize the page and helps users decide whether to click a link.

Where the Signal Actually Shows Up

The keyword-in-URL signal influences ranking in a few specific ways:

Anchor text matching. When someone links to your page and uses the URL as the anchor text (which happens more than you'd think in citations, forum posts, and plain-text emails), the keywords in that URL become part of the anchor text signal.

Snippet display. Google bolds matching keywords in the displayed URL within search results. A URL like yoursite.com/keyword-in-url will show the search term bolded, which can improve click-through rate — arguably more valuable than any direct ranking boost.

Crawl context. The URL path gives Googlebot one more signal about what a page covers. It's not decisive, but when combined with title, H1, and content, it reinforces topical relevance.

New Pages vs. Existing Pages: Different Rules

This distinction matters more than almost anything else in this discussion.

For new pages, yes — include the primary keyword in the URL if it fits naturally. Keep the URL short, use hyphens between words, and drop stop words (a, the, for, of). /project-management-software beats /the-best-project-management-software-for-teams. The former is cleaner, still keyword-rich, and easier to share.

For existing pages, almost never change the URL just to add keywords. The cost — losing accumulated link equity, triggering redirect chains, potentially breaking internal links — will hurt you more than the keyword signal will help. The only scenario where it's worth considering is a page with zero backlinks, poor performance, and a genuinely terrible URL like /page?id=4471.

This is the same logic that applies to keyword in domain name decisions — the signal is real but rarely worth structural disruption to capture it.

How to Structure URLs That Actually Work

A good URL is short, readable, and topically clear. That usually means it contains the target keyword naturally — not because you stuffed it in, but because the keyword describes what the page is about.

What to do:

What to avoid:

Keyword placement across your page — title, H1, URL, first paragraph — works as a system. The URL is one piece of that system, not the lever that drives everything.

The Click-Through Rate Angle

One underrated reason to care about your URL structure: how it looks in search results affects whether people click.

Google typically displays the breadcrumb path of your URL in the snippet. A clean, readable URL like yoursite.com › guides › keyword-in-url reads as more authoritative and relevant than yoursite.com › p=3847. Users make click decisions in fractions of a second, and a URL that matches their search query — with those terms bolded — can meaningfully lift CTR even if the raw ranking position doesn't change.

Higher CTR signals to Google that your result is satisfying users, which can reinforce rankings over time. So the URL's influence on ranking isn't only direct — it works through user behavior too.

What Matters More Than the URL

If you're allocating attention, here's the honest priority order for on-page SEO signals:

  1. Content quality and depth — does the page actually answer what the keyword is asking?
  2. Title tag — the strongest on-page keyword signal
  3. H1 — should match or closely echo the title
  4. Body content — natural use of the target keyword and related terms
  5. URL — useful, but well down the list

Spending an hour agonizing over URL structure when your page's content is thin is the wrong trade. The URL won't save a weak page. A strong page will rank even with an imperfect URL. For a deeper look at getting keyword optimization right across the whole page, start there before you spend time on URL tweaks.

When URL Keywords Do Move the Needle

There's a scenario where keyword-in-URL does noticeably help: competitive queries where the top-ranking pages are otherwise nearly equal. When Google is choosing between two similarly authoritative pages with similarly good content, the URL can be one of the tiebreakers. This matters more in local SEO and long-tail niches than in broad competitive categories where content and links are the dominant signals.

For sites trying to scale content and capture a lot of long-tail traffic — the kind of work services like Rankfill help map and execute — getting URL structure right from the start across hundreds of pages matters more than optimizing a single URL obsessively.

The Practical Takeaway

Include the keyword in your URL when it's natural and you're building a new page. Keep URLs short and readable. Never change an established URL just to add a keyword. And don't let the URL be your primary SEO focus — it's a supporting signal, not a ranking engine.

The sites ranking well aren't winning because of clever URL construction. They're winning because their content is thorough, their site is fast, and they've built pages that match what searchers actually want. The URL just helps communicate that to Google — it doesn't create it.

FAQ

Does repeating a keyword in the URL help? No. Repeating it (/seo-tips-best-seo-tips) looks spammy and doesn't add signal. Use the keyword once, naturally.

Should I include my keyword in subfolders too? Not unless it adds clarity. /services/web-design is fine. Engineering /services/web-design-services/web-design-packages around keywords creates noise, not signal.

What if my CMS generates ugly URLs automatically? Override them where possible. Most CMS platforms let you set a custom slug. A clean, keyword-relevant slug is worth the extra minute it takes.

Does URL length affect rankings? Not directly, but shorter URLs are easier to share, less likely to break in emails, and look cleaner in search results. Keep them as short as they can be while still being descriptive.

Should the URL match the title tag exactly? Roughly, not exactly. The title might be "Keyword in URL: Does It Still Matter for SEO in 2024?" — the URL should be /keyword-in-url, not the entire phrase. Drop filler words and formatting.

What about stop words like "the," "a," or "for"? Drop them from URLs. They add length without adding meaning or ranking signal.

If I redirect an old URL to a new one with a keyword, does that help? The new URL will carry the keyword signal, but you'll lose some link equity in the redirect — typically estimated at 85–99% pass-through with a 301. For a page with meaningful backlinks, the math rarely works in your favor.